You are here: Home / Race Days / Canterbury Racing - 6 October 2018 / Canterbury R 6 October 2018 - R 2 - Chair, Mr S Ching

Canterbury R 6 October 2018 - R 2 - Chair, Mr S Ching

Created on 09 October 2018

Rules:
638(1)(d)
Committee:
SChing (chair)
DAnderson
Name(s):
T Comignaghi-Class B Rider
D Walsh- Apprentice Jockey Mentor
Informant
M Williamson- Stipendiary Steward
Information Number
A11063
Plea:
Admitted
Charge:
Alleged breach of Rule 638(1)(d)-Careless riding
Evidence:

Following the running of Race 2, the Pryde’s Easifeed Maiden, an Information was filed by Stipendiary Steward, Mr M Williamson, against Class B Rider, Miss T Comignaghi alleging careless riding in that she permitted her mount, UBETIAM, to shift in when not clear of SUFFRAGETTE, ridden by Mr A Calder, which was checked passing the 1100m.

“(1) A Rider shall not ride a horse in a manner which the Judicial Committee considers to be:

(d) careless”

Miss Comignaghi had indicated on the Information that this breach of the Rules was admitted, which she confirmed at the hearing. Miss Comignaghi also agreed that she understood the charge and the Rule it was brought under. Mr D Walsh, NZTR Apprentice Mentor, assisted Miss Comignaghi at the hearing.

Mr Williamson gave evidence and used video coverage, with the assistance of Stipendiary Steward, Mr M Davidson, to show that nearing the 1100m, UBETIAM, ridden by Miss Comignaghi was racing on the outside of the leader, SUFFRAGETTE, ridden by Mr A Calder. Mr Davidson pointed out on the videos, Miss Comignaghi, improve forward on the outside of Mr Calder and shift across to assume the lead. Mr Davidson said Miss Comignaghi was not clear when shifting in and was at best a bare length ahead of Mr Calder, not the clearance required under the rules, resulting in him having to check. He said when Mr Calder restrained his mount, his mount over reacted and threw its head in the air a number of times. However, Mr Davidson said, Miss Comignaghi was not clear in this manoeuvre when crossing Mr Calder.

Mr Walsh said it was clear cut Miss Comignaghi had shifted across when not clear. He said Mr Calder’s horse did over react, when being restrained which may not have happened had the horse come back to him as normal. He said there was a small degree of carelessness by Miss Comignaghi but with Mr Calder’s horse overreacting, made the incident look worse than it was.

Decision:

As Miss Comignaghi had admitted the breach, the charge was found proved.

Submission For Penalty:

Mr Williamson stated that Miss Comignaghi’s record showed she had received a 6 National day suspension on 7 April 2018 at Riccarton, a 7 National day suspension on 29 April 2018 at Marlborough, 5 months prior, and just recently, a 5-day suspension at Riccarton on 22 September. Mr Williamson said the breach was low range with the JCA Penalty guide providing a 6 national day starting point. He said that consideration also be given to Miss Comignaghi’s ready admission of the breach and her penalty record which was slightly worse than neutral, as factors to consider in penalty.

Miss Comignaghi and Mr Walsh elected to make no submissions on penalty.

Deferment was discussed with Miss Comignaghi opting to take any suspension as soon as possible which would be after the continuation of today’s meeting on Tuesday 9 October.

Reasons For Penalty:

The JCA Penalty Guide for a low-range breach of this rule is a 6 National day suspension. The Committee also assessed this breach as low-range and therefore adopted the 6 National day starting point. Miss Comignaghi’s record showed 3 breaches over the past 12 months being 6 days at Riccarton on 7 April, 7 days at Marlborough on 29 April and only 2 weeks prior, a 5-day suspension at Riccarton on 22 September. Her most recent suspension is an aggravating factor which we determined, warranted an uplift in penalty, which we set at 1 day. We were, however, able to afford Miss Comignaghi, a discount for her frank admission of the breach which we set at 1 day.

We therefore determined that a 6 National-day suspension was an appropriate penalty in this case.

Penalty:

Miss Comignaghi’s Class B Jockeys licence is suspended from the conclusion of racing 9 October up to and including 17 October 2018.

Document Actions